Research · States

Postings and hiring moved together in 20 of 24 comparable state markets

A historical comparison of Q4 2025 finds broad agreement between advertised demand and actual hiring, after excluding small or unavailable changes.

Published November 6, 2026 · Edited November 13, 2026 · Data through December 31, 2025

Online job postings offer a timely view of employers’ recruiting plans. Census hiring records arrive later and tell us whether employers actually brought people onto their payrolls. Comparing the two for the same period helps test how well the quicker signal describes hiring activity.

For Q4 2025, the two measures moved in the same year-over-year direction in 20 of 24 qualifying state reporting areas, including Washington, D.C. Four moved in opposite directions. That is an 83.3% agreement rate within this selected group.

Direction of hiring rates and postings in Q4 2025

Year-over-year changes; 24 qualifying areas, including D.C.

Same direction20
Opposite directions4

state reporting areas

Each area counts once. Areas below either change cutoff or without sufficient data are excluded.

Source: Census Quarterly Workforce Indicators; Indeed Hiring Lab job postings index

View chart figures
ComparisonPeriod or groupValueUnit
Direction of hiring rates and postings in Q4 2025Same direction20state reporting areas
Direction of hiring rates and postings in Q4 2025Opposite directions4state reporting areas

The selection matters. An area entered the comparison only if its hiring rate changed by at least 2% and its postings index changed by at least 5%, in either direction. Areas with smaller changes or insufficient data are outside the denominator. The result cannot be read as an 83.3% agreement rate across the entire country.

The measures also answer different questions. The Census rate divides quarterly hires by beginning-of-quarter employment. The Indeed measure averages the postings index within the quarter. Agreement means both rose or both fell from a year earlier; it does not mean they changed by the same amount or that an advertised opening became a hire.

This supports using postings as one signal of local hiring conditions, with a check against employment records when those records become available. It does not establish that postings predict subsequent hiring: this comparison aligns the same quarter in both sources.

QWI’s publication lag makes this a study of Q4 2025, not a reading of today’s labor market. Each qualifying area receives equal weight, so a small state counts as much as a large one. Both sources can be revised.

Correction · November 13, 2026: The chart now shows the agreement comparison described in the article. The previous chart showed only hiring-rate changes despite referring to both measures.

Data & methodology

Data through
December 31, 2025; December 31, 2025
Retrieved
November 2, 2026; November 2, 2026

JobMarketHealth compares Q4 2025 with Q4 2024 using Census Quarterly Workforce Indicators and Indeed Hiring Lab. Both series are not seasonally adjusted. QWI hires are divided by beginning-of-quarter employment; suppressed or distorted values are excluded. Indeed quarterly averages require at least 12 stored Friday observations. The comparison includes only areas meeting the 2% hiring-rate and 5% postings-change cutoffs. Source: Indeed Hiring Lab. JobMarketHealth analysis of Indeed Hiring Lab data.

Suggested citation

JobMarketHealth. (2026-11-06). Postings and hiring moved together in 20 of 24 comparable state markets. https://jobmarkethealth.com/research/state-hires-rates-and-job-postings-direction-run-2026-11-02-629d16de7260

How JobMarketHealth research works